EDIT: This post if out of date and will not be updated.
from the hits on my post about warbook, the game certainly seems to be popular but having been part of the game now for 2 weeks, it feels that with bugs, performance problems and a number of now quite widely known ways of cheating, the game has reached past its peak. Some of the more established players, having got to around level 15 and above have quit, the game having either lost its challenge (and thus novelty) or because of the success of cheaters in it.
Even without the cheaters, I cant see the game lasting that long. The essence of its play is quite simple and resembles a pyramid. The stronger players feed off the weaker players. There’s little reason to fight to the death as this leaves you vulnerable to more attackers of weaker strength. Those who can either avoid retaliation (hence holding on to their strength) and there are a few methods to do this (some legal, some not so), tend to rise to the top. Actually, those who have the most time on their hands tend to also do well.
Anyway, I cant see myself being interested for much longer. And that is a good thing. However, I’m now more interested in other online strategy games (such as Utopia by Swirve – very similar to warbook but much more complex and a lot older). And that is a very bad thing indeed.
Well, a few weeks later and i’m still intermittently playing.
The number of exploits and cheaters in the game are so high that I keep expecting it to die off in popularity but this does not seem to be happening. Instead, the hits on this page and my other strategy / tips page is totalling to around 140 or so a day – which can only indicate that there are a lot of new players joining.
The tone of the warbook forum has also remained consistent. Most of the players on it air various dissatisfactions either with cheaters or with people who abuse various unwritten protocols of behaviour or with game rules that do not suit them. The players have a point though – the problem of balance and playability has not been solved (especially with regard to players that have assisted each other in leveling up). Still I do not know how the game administrators put up with the constant complaints – I would have long ago abandoned the forum.
However, one area that can certainly be improved is game administrator communications to the community. It is difficult to find out what rules have changed in an update and when the next update (along with planned changes) are due. The discussion room format prepared by Facebook is just not good for presenting static information. Threads are too quickly buried.
Even though I am still looking on, I predict that unless some changes are put in place (and I do not know what they are), warbook will not be around next year.